ASRO Governed Public Review Docket

Docket identity

Review id: review-asro-reference-docket-2026-07-27
Schema: governed-framework-review.v1
Framework: AI Systems Reliability Operator (ASRO)
Relevant time T: 2026-07-27T08:20:00Z
Current standing: PROVISIONAL
Reconstruction status: PARTIAL
Challenge status: OPEN
Verified capabilities: none
External ASRO-native execution: NOT_RUN
Certification granted: false
Execution authority granted: false

This is the second governed public-review docket under the Wiki public-anchor model. It converts the existing ASRO crosswalk, bounded comparison, replay record, and reconstruction record into a time-bound, challengeable, machine-readable review.

Framework-native declaration

ASRO is publicly framed as an independent AI governance-state attestation system that can witness whether an AI system remained within its declared governance state over time.

The current review binds that declaration to:

https://aisystemsreliability.org/
https://github.com/magicianzcardstockllc/asro

The public sources are not currently bound to a frozen external release hash or canonical source snapshot.

StegVerse-derived boundary

StegVerse currently maps ASRO as an external evidence and attestation surface. ASRO evidence may support an admissibility review, but it does not independently issue StegVerse execution authority.

ASRO asks: Was the system operating under the governance state it claimed?
Admissibility asks: May this transition bind consequence at commit time?
EVIDE asks: What evidence remains after the event?

Capability matrix

Capability	Classification	Evidence posture
Governance-state attestation	DECLARED	Official public source and repository references.
Declared-reference collection membership	OBSERVED	StegVerse bounded comparison only.
Deterministic replay of the frozen comparison package	OBSERVED	Published JSONL event stream and bounded receipt.
Reconstruction of the frozen comparison package	OBSERVED / PARTIAL	StegVerse package reconstructed; native ASRO behavior was not reconstructed.
External ASRO-native execution	NOT_RUN	No frozen external runtime output observed.
Native interoperability	UNRESOLVED	External execution, configuration, version, issuer, and independent reproduction remain absent.
Execution authority	NONE	Attestation evidence does not inherit authority.

No capability is recorded as independently verified at this time.

Installed bounded test

Test: asro-declared-reference-membership-v1
Executor: StegVerse
Result: PASS
Correspondence: ESTABLISHED
Replay: PASS
Reconstruction: PASS within the frozen package
External ASRO-native execution: NOT_RUN
Authority: NONE

The observed result demonstrates that the StegVerse comparison package can bind declared-reference membership, preserve an event stream, and reconstruct its own bounded result. It does not demonstrate native ASRO implementation behavior.

Evidence registry

Official source:
  https://aisystemsreliability.org/

Public repository:
  https://github.com/magicianzcardstockllc/asro

Frozen test case:
  /data/framework-evaluations/test-cases/asro-declared-reference-membership-v1.json

StegVerse event stream:
  /data/framework-evaluations/runs/asro-declared-reference-membership-v1-stegverse-run-001.jsonl

Bounded receipt:
  /receipts/asro-bounded-comparison-run-001.json

Machine-readable docket:
  /data/governed-framework-reviews/asro.reference-docket.v1.json

Bounded determination

ASRO is provisionally mapped as an external governance-state attestation and evidence surface. The StegVerse bounded comparison demonstrates correspondence, replay, and reconstruction only within the frozen comparison package. External ASRO-native execution and accountable reviewer issuance remain unresolved.

This determination is evidence-bound and may be corrected, challenged, superseded, or withdrawn as stronger evidence becomes available.

Public Reconstruction Procedure

An independent reviewer can reconstruct the current docket by:

1. inspecting the official ASRO source and public repository;
2. reading the frozen declared-reference membership test;
3. replaying the published event sequence;
4. checking the bounded receipt against the declared result;
5. confirming that external ASRO-native execution remains NOT_RUN;
6. confirming that no admissibility, authority, certification, custody, or interoperability claim is inherited from correspondence;
7. submitting any difference through the framework reconstruction submission object.

Challenge and correction path

A challenge should identify:

review id
challenged field or determination
relevant time T
supporting evidence
reconstruction method
observed difference
requested action
conflict declaration

A reconstruction submission does not automatically change standing. Any accepted correction must produce a durable correction receipt preserving the prior state, changed fields, basis, dissent, and resulting standing effect.

Unresolved dependencies

- versioned ASRO source snapshot and source hash
- frozen external ASRO implementation version
- external runtime configuration
- raw ASRO-native output
- accountable reviewer issuer
- independent external reproduction
- reciprocal framework response

Authority boundary

correspondence != truth
correspondence != sufficiency
correspondence != validity
correspondence != admissibility
correspondence != authority inheritance
replay PASS != external execution
reconstruction PASS != execution authority
public review != certification
publication != custody

Publication creates no execution authority. The docket records the standing supported by current evidence and preserves a public path for reconstruction, correction, dissent, and supersession.