ASRO External Framework Crosswalk
Generated Evaluation Status
This section is generated from the framework manifest and compatibility report. Do not edit it manually.
- Framework ID:
asro - Manifest:
docs/external-frameworks/asro.json - Compatibility report:
./reports/asro.compatibility.json - Evidence class:
ARTIFACT_REVIEWED - Independently reproducible:
False - Comparative-testing claim allowed:
False - Missing reproducibility gates:
shared_test_vector, raw_output, timestamp, runtime_configuration, source_version_or_hash, replay_commands, declared_expected_outcome, independent_reproduction - Evaluation result:
COMPATIBILITY_EVIDENCE_ONLY - Cycle status:
FIRST_FRAMEWORK_CYCLE_COMPLETE - Execution authority claim:
False - Next bounded action: Add executable observations, raw outputs, pinned versions, replay commands, and independent reproduction before making comparative-testing claims.
- Posting source: generated compatibility report
- Generated status is descriptive compatibility evidence only.
Generated Authored Analysis Boundary
This section is generated. Do not edit it manually.
- Framework ID:
asro - Framework name:
ASRO - Generated sections above this boundary may be rebuilt from registry, manifest, compatibility-report, and result artifacts.
- Authored analysis below this boundary may contain interpretation, notes, and framework-specific discussion.
- Generators must preserve authored analysis unless a future validator explicitly declares a migration path.
- Boundary rule: generated material is descriptive compatibility evidence only and does not create certification, endorsement, adoption, proof, or operational permission.
Generated Transition Mapping
This section is generated from the framework manifest. Do not edit it manually.
| Field | Generated Value |
|---|---|
framework_identity | ASRO |
source_reference | https://aisystemsreliability.org/ |
source_version | public source and repository recorded |
allowed_use_boundary | governance-state attestation crosswalk evidence only |
claims | host-side governance-state measurement, edge-side witnessing, verifier reconciliation, governance-state change record, selective-attestation threat model |
non_claims | no admissibility proof, certification, endorsement, legal compliance guarantee, output-quality evaluation, or execution authority |
input_artifact_type | attestation record or governance-state evidence artifact |
output_artifact_type | crosswalk and compatibility evidence |
actor_or_authority_model | external attestation posture; no StegVerse authority inherited |
evidence_model | host measurement, edge witnessing, verifier reconciliation, and governance-state change records |
policy_or_rule_model | declared governance-state and change-record comparison |
delegation_model | not asserted by wiki entry |
decision_or_result_model | attestation evidence only |
execution_authority_claim | false |
receipt_or_trace_model | source reference, repository reference, and wiki record |
reconstruction_model | source plus crosswalk can reconstruct governance-state attestation relationship limits |
SPE_overlap | may inform evidence and review posture, not standing determination |
StegVerse_ecosystem_overlap | Evidence Posture, Receipt-Bound Execution, Reconstructability, Drift, Commit-Time Validity |
fail_closed_conditions | missing source, undefined mapping, selective attestation uncertainty, or authority overclaim |
Generated mapping is compatibility evidence only.
Generated Framework Metadata
This section is generated from the external-framework registry. Do not edit it manually.
- Framework ID:
asro - Name:
ASRO - Registry status:
SOURCED-CROSSWALK-PROVISIONAL - Testbench state:
SOURCE_RECORDED_CROSSWALK_PROVISIONAL - Manifest path:
docs/external-frameworks/asro.json - Source reference:
https://aisystemsreliability.org/ - Metadata boundary: generated metadata is descriptive only; it does not create certification, endorsement, formalism adoption, admissibility proof, or execution authority.
Status
Relationship type: external framework crosswalk
Canonical StegVerse formalism source: Admissible-Existence
External framework role: independent AI governance-state attestation
Wiki role: evidence-layer observatory, comparison, and relationship review
Citation status: sourced
Evidence provenance status: bounded comparison packet installed
Live reciprocal execution: NOT_TESTED
Reviewer issuer: unresolved
Source
Public source: https://aisystemsreliability.org/
Public repository: https://github.com/magicianzcardstockllc/asro
The public source is treated as the canonical public source supplied for ASRO framing. The repository is treated as the public artifact source for the ASRO v1.0 release-candidate materials described by the source site.
Evidence Provenance
| Evidence Class | Current Evidence | Status | Missing Fields |
|---|---|---|---|
| Official Framework Sources | Public ASRO source URL. | present | Versioned source snapshot and source hash. |
| Official Implementation Sources | Public ASRO repository URL. | present_repository_reference | Specific release, commit hash, and artifact package snapshot. |
| Observed Behavior | Commitment Candidate fixture is referenced; no reproduced runtime/attestation run is claimed here. | commitment_candidate_material_present_or_pending | Raw attestation output, verifier payload, timestamp, source version, and hash. |
| Reproduced Behavior | No independent reproduction is claimed. | not_started | Reproduction fixture and deterministic ASRO verification run. |
| StegVerse Analysis | Host-side measurement, edge-side witnessing, verifier reconciliation, governance-state changes, and selective attestation are mapped to admissibility primitives. | governance_state_attestation_crosswalk | SPE review over concrete attestation artifacts. |
| Interoperability Assessment | ASRO evidence may support a Commitment Candidate without becoming execution authority. | pending_or_partial_commitment_candidate | Completed fixture validation report and compatibility report. |
| Bounded Comparison | ASRO-author-provided bounded representative object and StegVerse Companion Layer declaration are installed. | correspondence_packet_installed | Frozen shared test case, JSONL execution, replay, and reconstruction. |
| Standing | Sourced provisional. | provisional | Release/commit hash and validation artifact package. |
Evidence classification:
F1: ASRO public source URL and framework-native public framing.
F2: ASRO public repository reference.
V1: ASRO non-authorizing Commitment Candidate fixture reference.
S1: StegVerse interpretation of ASRO as governance-state attestation evidence.
S2: mapping to Evidence Posture, Policy Reference, Governance Boundary, Reconstructability, Receipt-Bound Execution, Review Posture, Drift, Commit-Time Validity, and FAIL-CLOSED behavior.
I1: pending until the ASRO artifact is routed through a validated Commitment Candidate/SPE fixture.
B1: ASRO-author-provided bounded representative object; non-canonical and not asserted to be an existing released ASRO-native schema.
B2: StegVerse Companion Layer declaration; controlling source declaration for StegVerse terminology.
B3: reviewer-side profile; derivative with issuer unresolved.
Definition
ASRO, the AI Systems Reliability Operator, is treated in this wiki as an external evidence and attestation framework for independently witnessing whether an AI system remained within its declared governance state over time.
ASRO is not treated as an admissibility engine, safety certification, legal-compliance guarantor, or output-quality evaluator.
Framework-Term Definitions
| Native ASRO Term | Definition For This Wiki | Reconciliation Class | Admissibility Relationship |
|---|---|---|---|
| ASRO | Independent attestation layer for AI governance-state continuity. | new | Preserved as framework-native terminology. |
| Host Meter Agent | Operator-side measurement component that observes governance-state declarations and changes. | adjacent | Related to Evidence Posture and Receipt-Bound Execution. |
| Edge Meter Agent | User-side or dependent-party witnessing component for governance-state attestation. | adjacent | Related to external witness evidence and reconstructability. |
| ASRO Verifier | Independent reconciliation component comparing host-side measurement and edge-side witnessing. | adjacent | Related to independent authority reconstruction evidence, but not execution authority itself. |
| Governance state | The declared policies, tools, constraints, configuration, or rules under which the AI system claims to operate. | adjacent | Related to Policy Reference, Governance Boundary, and Commit-Time Validity. |
| Selective attestation | Failure mode where a system attests enough to preserve plausible compliance while hiding governance-relevant change. | adjacent | Related to drift, evidence incompleteness, and FAIL-CLOSED review posture. |
Relationship To Admissibility
ASRO is listed as a crosswalk target for governance-state attestation and independent witnessing.
Admissibility review remains separate and asks whether a proposed transition may bind consequence at commit time.
In StegVerse terms, ASRO evidence may support a Commitment Candidate by supplying independently witnessed governance-state records. Those records remain evidence. They do not become execution authority.
Crosswalk Targets
| ASRO Candidate Function | Wiki / AE Relationship |
|---|---|
| Host-side governance-state measurement | Evidence Posture; Policy Reference; Governance Boundary |
| Edge-side witnessing | Reconstructability; Receipt-Bound Execution |
| Independent verifier reconciliation | Review Posture; independent authority reconstruction evidence |
| Governance-state change record | Drift; Commit-Time Validity; Receipt-Bound Execution |
| Selective-attestation threat model | FAIL-CLOSED behavior; evidence sufficiency review |
Commitment Candidate Fixture
ASRO is connected to a non-authorizing Commitment Candidate fixture:
docs/external-frameworks/asro-commitment-candidate.json
The fixture records how an ASRO governance-state attestation artifact may be routed into StegVerse review without converting the attestation into execution authority.
The fixture's default posture is FAIL-CLOSED unless current policy, delegation, evidence, context, and recoverability are independently reconstructed at the commit boundary.
Bounded comparison packet
The installed bounded comparison surface consists of:
static/data/framework-evaluations/asro/stegverse-companion-layer-declaration.json
static/data/framework-evaluations/asro/asro-author-provided-bounded-representative-object.json
static/data/framework-evaluations/asro/reviewer-profile.json
static/data/framework-evaluations/asro/correspondence-manifest.json
static/data/framework-evaluations/asro/expected-results.json
static/data/framework-evaluations/asro.json
The ASRO-side object is an ASRO-author-provided bounded representative object. It is non-canonical and is not represented as an existing released ASRO-native schema.
The StegVerse Companion Layer declaration remains controlling. The reviewer-side profile is expressly derivative and may not modify the source declaration's meaning.
Reference and collection-membership rule
Declared-reference presence does not reduce to label equality. The comparison must establish explicit collection membership and bind the reference to:
object identity
relevant version
content hash
applicable time reference
collection identity
A nominal label match without these bindings is unresolved and fails closed.
Reviewer and issuer separation
external_reviewer_comparison_surface identifies a role. It does not identify an accountable issuer.
Until a reviewer is actually designated, the honest state is:
issuer: unresolved
Any eventual reviewer record must separately carry role, identity, authority basis, methodology/version, and provenance.
Correspondence boundary
The installed manifest establishes correspondence only:
correspondence != truth
correspondence != sufficiency
correspondence != validity
correspondence != admissibility
correspondence != authority inheritance
correspondence != execution authority
correspondence != custody transfer
ASRO remains an evidence-preservation and integrity review surface in this comparison. StegVerse alone issues any StegVerse admissibility result through its own governed transition process.
Three-Part Boundary
ASRO asks: Was the system operating under the governance state it claimed?
Admissibility asks: May this transition bind consequence at commit time?
EVIDE asks: What evidence remains after the event?
Non-Claims
ASRO is not a StegVerse canonical formalism.
ASRO does not prove transition admissibility.
ASRO does not grant execution authority inside StegVerse.
ASRO source citation is not acceptance of equivalence.
ASRO attestation evidence may support review, but review does not become authority.
The bounded representative object is not a released ASRO-native schema.
The reviewer role is not an accountable issuer.
Correspondence does not inherit authority.
Challenge Path
A reader may challenge this reflection by identifying the claim, challenged field, reason, supporting evidence, and requested correction or standing change.
Mandatory Footer
This page reflects a bounded admissibility packet. Publication does not create standing. The reflected claim inherits only the standing that can be reconstructed from the referenced evidence, authority, and admissibility conditions.
Next Safe Build Target
Freeze the shared ASRO comparison test case, generate the first JSONL execution record, and add replay and reconstruction validators without creating a second active workflow.